Skip to content
Back to all essays
George's Takes

I approved AI work I didn't check

By George PuEssay2 min read

Published

An editor inspects a page through a magnifying glass while pausing an approval stamp.

The first version of this essay was about checking AI work.

AI wrote most of it.

I approved it. It went live.

Good ideas. Real studies. Careful, balanced, a tidy disclosure at the bottom.

It didn't sound like me.

There was no person in it.

That's the whole problem.

A few months ago I rebuilt the tools behind Founder Reality around AI.

I wanted more output. I got more output.

I didn't like what came out.

My old tools were better. So we're changing everything.

AI wasn't the mistake.

Approving it because it looked finished was.

Vinci taught me the same thing from the other side.

We tested a lot of models.

What surprised me - how raw they are without the internet.

They make things up. Confidently.

DeepSeek V4 Flash cited a paper that doesn't exist. Clean title. Clean summary. Never written.

And it's not one model. It's most of them.

Add a harness and web search and it drops a lot. That's how we ship.

But a harness isn't a fix.

It's good masking.

The hallucination is still underneath.

So is the forgetting - the thing you told it an hour ago, gone.

So approving AI work blindly is stupid.

Especially content. Especially editorial.

The whole point is that a person meant it.

Contrarian take - I think the NYT and WSJ will be fine.

Journalists are real people talking to real people.

A source calls back. A source says something off the record that changes the story.

A model can't get that. And it can't be accountable for it.

Their threat isn't AI.

It's TikTok. It's the feed.

The people who should worry are the ones publishing confident text nobody checked.

For one day, that was me.

Next time your name goes on something AI made, ask one thing.

What would let me say no?

If the answer is nothing - you didn't check it.

You trusted it.

I run SimpleDirect. We build Vinci. I see this every day.

Share this:

New essays and letters, by email

Subscribe if you would like to hear from me when I have something worth sending. Everything here remains free to read.

Optional. Unsubscribe anytime.