Skip to content
← All tools

Is AI saving time or money?

Count the whole task, including checking and fixing. Then see whether any spending falls.

Hypothetical examples. Inputs stay on this page unless you choose to save or export them.

Full worksheet · edit every assumption

For salaried work with unchanged payroll, leave cash realization at 0%. Freed time may increase capacity; it becomes cash savings only when you can actually reduce spending. Rework is additional to normal verification. Include retry/API costs in the average per-attempt price.

All results, setup payback and limits

Compare the scenario

Manual human time / month
60.0 hours
AI workflow human time / month
20.0 hours
Human time freed / month
40.0 hours
Freed capacity value / month (not cash)
$1,200.00
AI recurring cost / month
$100.00
Assumed spending avoided / month
$0.00
Net assumed cash savings / month
-$100.00
Net time-value benefit / month
$1,100.00
Cash setup payback
No payback at these assumptions
Setup payback including human time value
0.7 months
Monthly volume for recurring cash break-even
No break-even at these assumptions
Net assumed cash savings over 6 months
-$1,100.00
Net human time freed over 6 months, after setup
230.0 hours

Use this result

This scenario models 40.0 hours of freed human time per month and $100.00 extra monthly cash spending. These are assumptions, not measured outcomes.

Check one assumption: Count checking time, rejected attempts and fixes for the same set of tasks.

Choose one task and decide what a good result looks like
Method and limits

Expected human minutes per AI attempt = operation + verification + failure fraction × extra rework. Monthly time freed = attempts × (manual minutes − AI human minutes) ÷ 60. Capacity value multiplies those hours by your hourly value. Assumed spending avoided uses only positive capacity value × cash realization fraction. Net cash savings subtract AI per-attempt and incremental fixed costs. Cash payback divides setup cash by positive monthly cash savings; the separate time-value payback also includes setup hours. Break-even volume covers recurring fixed cost only, excluding setup. Horizon results subtract setup once.

This expected-value model assumes constant volume, prices, human time and failure rate. It excludes discounting, taxes, ramp-up, downstream harm from missed errors and changing quality. All example values are hypothetical. Measure representative successful and failed attempts; a lower apparent failure rate is useful only if your verification can detect meaningful errors. Compare scenarios with longer verification, more rework and lower cash realization before adopting a workflow. There is no model or provider price feed.

A dated public account, with measurements still missing

George's three-person-team AI cost account, published , reports spending and token/cache usage. It does not report an exact comparison window, manual task baseline, acceptance criteria, accepted/rejected outputs or human review and rework minutes.

It cannot establish measured cost per accepted result or time saved. The calculator keeps its hypothetical example; no trial inputs are inferred from that bill. A complete trial record with those measurements remains unavailable.

Read the annotation and design your own comparison →